This Encyclopedia has very strict standards regarding the adoption or creation of mountain names. The standards are published on this website. Our goal is to promote useful names for maps and articles. Our criteria for picking among possible names is the most comprehensive I have seen. The practice of naming unnamed peaks is common with many notable guidebooks, as a necessity for orderly discussion of the peaks. This encyclopedia has continued that process, but this time, we have also documented the process. For example, we publish a set of Mountain Names Cases for the naming principles.
Every name adopted in Bivouac has one of the following "Title Statuses" as described in Title Status Dictionary, In general, what we want are short, easy to use names, good for maps.
ISSUES
The title status and primary name of peaks can not be directly edited. They can only be changed by sending an email to R Tivy. Any editor can add name information to the "name notes" field, but the main "MtnTitle" field can only be changed via email request.
Co-ordination of Names
Considerable effort has gone into standardizing names with other sources. This includes the government, guidebooks, third party maps, and other websites. We are in constant communication with many guidebook authors, and other list makers. We sometimes have had to reverse names previously adopted by Bivouac, if older established names become known. The general principle is to standardize our names with whatever is out there, even if the other name has some shortfalls.
See also Mountain Names Cases. The test cases refer to the principles, and in some cases, established the principles.
Any dispute concerning names should refer to the naming principles documents.
See Properties of a Good Name/
Changing Names:
We make every effort to use local names. Any local name should at least be reflected in the "Alternate Names" field, so people can find it when searching.
In some cases where a Bivouac name is not well established, I will actually change the primary name to correspond to the local name, and put the old primary as a secondary. However, I have to use considerable caution in this practice, because there may be various references to the original Bivouac name.