Bivouac.com   Home     Help   Index   SignUp   Login
Naming Rights #635
    Date first written: 2005.11.22   Review Date:2016.07.11

Who has the right to "name" peaks? What is a good name? In general, a peak tend to get names as soon as someone wants to talk about it, for any purpose. Many peak names were created by "surveyors". This is the same principle all over the world, such as Mount Everest which was named long before it was climbed. In some cases, a name may be assigned to an unnamed peak in order to refer to its topographic significance. Again, so you could refer to it.

Not everybody agrees with how names are assigned. Some people have a notion of "naming rights" which says that naming can only be done by the first mountaineer to climb the peak or go into the area, has the "right" to name it. Eg: I am Alexander MacKenzie, and I claim all this land in the name of the King, and I call that mountain XXX, and that one over there YYY and so on. I'm not sure what they think about if that "first person" merely landed on the peak with a helicopter or drove up it with a snowmobile.

Others believe that the "naming rights" belong only to locals. That theory says that names applied by the government, by guidebook writers, or anyone else are not acceptable. There are several problems with this idea: first of all, there are hundreds of peaks on remote icecaps for which there are no "local" people. Second, the locals may have no involvement with the mountains. Who is a "local?". Someone logging the nearby valley?

One problem with the "locals" theory is that you get into an argument as to who was there first. Which leads to the theory that only first nations people have the right to name mountains. This idea leads to the problem of names being assigned just to stake out "ownership" of an area. There can often be two groups that both claim an area as their "traditional area". So both groups will come up with a name, and without written records, it is hard for historians to determine which name came first.

There is nothing wrong with different groups each having their own names to refer to peaks. The bivouac names are only for purposes of mountaineering discussions, and it's up to any given group to decide what names they want to use.

The bivouac objective was to find workable names for certain peaks we want to discuss and label on our maps. Assigning a new name is a last resort, and only done if there is not a good name already in use. But I'm not really approaching the subject of mountain naming from an "ownership" or "naming rights" point of view. The primary focus is how useful and convenient the name is.

So what is a "good" name? I guess the most important thing is that it be useable. So it should be short, unique, easy to pronounce, and easy to remember. And of course if there are already some people using the name, such as established guidebook names, or local names, then we use that.

If we are forced to make up a name, it should have some meaning to all Canadians, not just a select group of locals.

Using this criteria, perhaps it is useful to mention some names in the Bridge River area that I thought were reasonable. "Nosebag Peak" is a good name, because it tells all Canadians a bit about horses and the pioneers of this area. And Seton Peak is a good name, because it refers to a historic event that is part of our common heritage. And "Statimecets Peak" is a good name because it educates all Canadians about the presence of First Nations people in this area for thousands of years.

"Two Doctors Peak" is a bad name, because it is primarily of inside joke. Also "Bald Mountain" is a bad name because there are dozens of them already, and so it doesn't "work" as a unique identifier.

In summary, I'm not interested in an "ownership" war, whereby everybody rushes out and attaches their own names to things, as some sort of sign of their ownership. We are just writing a guidebook, not acting as an arm of the government. The tradition of guidebooks attaching names to peaks has existed since Thorington (1924) wrote the first guidebooks for the Canadian Rockies. Many of those names are still unofficial, but the tradition has been to carry them forward. Certainly a careful reading of Putnam's edition of the 1973 "The Rocky Mountains of Canada" reveals many names that were created for that guidebook. There's nothing that says these names must be used by local people. The names only exist if people want to use them.