There is also a Properties of a Good Name document, which indicates the importance of various factors. See Master List of Peak Name Documents
Table of Contents
1. Plural Names are Areas
2. Spot Height Names are Alternate
3. Confusing Names not Adopted
4. Ridges Are Areas, Not Peaks
5. Self Referential Names are avoided
6. Organization Names not favored
7. Correction Prefixes
1. Plural Names are Areas
We regard any plural name to be the name of an area, not a point. For example, we regard "Serra Peaks" to be a name that refers to a number of peaks, not just to the highest point. Similarly "Dogs Ear Peaks". We are especially strict on the word "Peak", but in theory other plurals such as "Spires" can also cause trouble.
1. If the area in question contains more than one peak which we want to discuss, then we enter a single area record, and multiple peak records. For example, we have an area record for Serra Peaks, and then each of the five peaks has its own peak record.
2. If the area in question really only contains one peak of interest, we take a shortcut, and just put in a peak record for the highest point, and give it a singular name, with the plural name as an alternate name. For example, we represent the area "Dogs Ear Peaks" with a single peak record called "Dogs Ear Peak", with the alternate name "Dogs Ear Peaks". However, if we ever get a reason to want more than one peak in that group, we would have to create a new name for the highest point. (Perhaps Dog Ear 1, Dog Ear 2, as with the Serra Peaks.
3. Spires, Towers, etc. We regard "Spires" to be a name that refers to an area and not a single point. Therefore, it should be handled the same way as "Peaks", and the highest point should be given a singular name. For example, Nesakwatch Spires is two distinct towers. Of course it could be handled as an area and then two peaks, but that is perhaps too much work. Another way to handle it would be to call the highest point "Nesakwatch Peak", with the alternate name Nesakwatch Spires. However, if the name is official, then such a name is messy, so as long as it doesn't cause trouble, we don't bother to fix it. The bivouac primary name is left as plural for some official names. We ignore the error. However, we do not intend to adopt unofficial plural names for peaks, any plural name is just trouble waiting to happen.
2. Spot Height Names are Alternate
Spot height names, such as "Peak 8431" are good alternate names, because you can find them on the map. The 1:50,000 maps contain spot heights, usually to the nearest foot, unless the map is metric, in which case to the nearest meter. These heights are really handy when looking at maps, because your eye can quickly spot the number. Eg: If somebody says "We went up peak 8431, you can easily see which peak they meant. Therefore if the peak has an exact spot height, we use it as an alternate name for the peak.
Eg: "Peak 8431"
However this policy does not extent to making up "height" names for peaks that do not have a spot height. In other words, we do not use Peak 8500 as an alternate name. On any given map, there might be a dozen Peak 8500's. Also there was confusion as to whether or not they should be translated into metric. So we go back to first principles - the only spot heights we use as names are ones that are actually printed on the map.
Some people have suggested that the spot heights should be used as the PRIMARY name for peaks. The problems with this are that the means of identifying the peak changes every time there is a new survey. Eg: Some of the USA trip reports in Alaska are now very difficult to figure out because the author referred to Peak 8721, but the latest maps are metric and also the height was almost 100 feet different. These names work really well when both people in the conversation are looking at the same map. But they don't work if one person is referring to "Peak 2307" and somebody else tries to look it up on a 1:50,000 which is in feet.
Metric Spot Height Names: Spot height names are normally based on feet, simply because the 1:50,000 maps are still in feet. However, if the latest edition of the 1:50,000 is in meters, then we use a metric spot height. Eg; the peaks around Jasper all have metric spot heights. Peak 2341. At some point there may be two maps in widespread circulation, in which case a peak may have both a metric and an imperial spot height name.
3. Confusing Names not Adopted
1. If a name is associated with contraversy and confusion, we avoid that name altogether. For example a name "Kunzleman Peak" was proposed for a peak, but there was two contradictory notes regarding its location, and so it is better to just use a different name that is clearly defined to be in a single location.
2. If someone puts forth a name with unsuitable semantics, such as a plural name, and does not agree with correcting the semantics, then we avoid using the name. Eg: When "Rune Ridges" was put forth as a name for a peak, it was tempting to use "Rune Peak" as the peak. However, since the "old climbers map" upon which the name was based called it "Rune Ridges", it is more sensible to just avoid the name entirely, and save future argument.
3. If there are two variations of the name, we avoid it.
4. Ridges Are Areas, Not Peaks
The Bivouac database has two distinct types of records: areas and mountains (peaks). A peak is a point feature, and has a single lat-long. An area is a polygon and has a boundary. This conforms with the government database, where ridges are a different type of feature from mountains. We regard anything named "ridge" to be the name of an area, not a point. For example, we regard "Nine Mile Ridge" as an area.
This conforms with the way most of them are labelled on maps - the printing for a ridge name is usually spread out over the area of the ridge, whereas the label for a point is usually horizontal, and beside the point being labelled.
1. Some ridges already have distinct names for the highest point. For example, the highest point on Mission ridge is Mount McLean.
2. Unfortunately, many ridges do not have a distinct name for the highest peak on the ridge. Therefore we have to assign one. If possible, we use the same name as the ridge. For example, we call the highest point on Hibachi Ridge "Hibachi Peak". We are NOT renaming the ridge, we are naming the previously unnamed high point. The "title status" should be geographic. (not official).
3. In some cases, the ridge is too small to warrant a separate area record. For example, Panorama Ridge only has one peak worth discussing. In these cases we take a shortcut, and just put in a record for Panorama Peak, and give it the alternate name "Panorama Ridge". That way if anyone searches for Panorama Ridge, they find the highest point. Note again that we are NOT renaming the ridge. We still regard the ridge to be called "Panorama Ridge", but we haven't bothered to put in an area record for it. Other examples are Playsoo Peak, (Playsoo Ridge).
4. In some cases, the name of the ridge is not a suitable base name for its highest point, because it is inherently confusing. For example, the name "Nine Mile Peak" is not suitable for the highest point on "Nine Mile Ridge" because the base name of the ridge is inherently an area name. Therefore in these cases we have to select a distinct name for the peak. The name for this point is currently Roderick Peak, named after the creek. It is also referred to sometimes as Servitude Peak. The title status in this case should be "Suggested", not geographic. This will show up as "unofficial".
Summary: The distinction betweeen area features and point features is not a new Bivouac invention. We have already mentioned that most of the officially named ridges are labelled as if they were areas, in that the name is spread across the area, and usually with a different font, whereas a peak name is of a uniform size. The second indicator is to look up a given ridge in the government database (BCGNIS). They are usually registered as a separate type of feature from a peak.
Some Classic Examples:
- Endless Chain Ridge.
- Rune Ridges
- Nine Mile Ridge
- Hibatchi Ridge
- Fountain Ridge
5. Self Referential Names are avoided
We avoid names that refer to the person or party doing the naming. Eg: Ride-In peak or Rhyddin Peak.
6. Organization Names not favored
We avoid names of organizations, and especially acronymns as becoming primary names of peaks or areas. For example, we avoid "PPCLi Ridges" which refers to "Princess Patricia's Canadian Light Infantry." Our policy is to avoid acronymns.
In many cases, organization names are just one step removed from naming peaks after ones self, or ones friends. The biggest offenders are various military groups naming peaks and ridges after themselves. Eg: RCAF peak is not a good name, even if it is an official.
7. Correction Prefixes
Avoid "correction prefixes" like "True" and "False".
If the higher peak is more than 1 km away, and is unnamed, assign it a new name. Eg: