Bivouac.com   Home     Help   Index   SignUp   Login
Designated Peaks #3529
    Date first written: 2022.03.15   Review Date:2022.03.15

Table of Contents
1. Preface
2. Criteria
3. Examples Summary Table
4. Frosty Mountain
5. Shulaps Peak
6. King Edward
7. Mount Routh
8. Mount Warner
9. Correction Policy

1. Preface
This document is an expansion of Title Status Dictionary. It specifically discusses the title status of "Designated". The purpose is to help decide what to do for situations which could result in the use of the status "Designated". A "designated" situation always involves two points. In most cases both points are "peaks" in the bivouac database, (eg: shulaps) but in other cases we do not clutter the database with both points (eg: King Edward).

So this document lists the "Criteria we look at in determining what to do. For example, with the Mount Routh situation, we have to decide whether or not to have 2 peaks in the database, and which one should be titled Mount Routh. See the separate chapter on this peak.

2. Criteria
Below is a list of considerations you could refer to in deciding any given case. No single fact decides the case, each fact only "suggests" what we should do. In some cases they contradict, as in Shulaps.

  1. Distance between points
     If the distance between the two peaks is less than 1 km, this suggests putting the known label on the highest point.

  2. Prominence
     If the prominence is more than 50m, this suggests putting both peaks into the database. Eg: Mount Routh there are two distinct peaks, whereas the south summit of King Edward has a very low prominence and thus would not warrant a separate peak.

  3. Time required to traverse
     If it would take less than 1 hour to traverse between the peaks, this suggests the highest point should be designated as the summit. Eg: Mount Mcbride on Vancouver island. However King Edward is an exception. Although there is very little prominence difference or distance between the two peaks, Rick Collier estimated it would take 4 hours to work ones way from one to the other. But we still don't bother with 2 peaks.

  4. Label placement
     The label for King Edward on the old 1:50 is clearly closer to the north end. On the toporama it is floating to the west of the north end.

  5. Google location
     If Google has already put the label onto the highest point, that suggests we should not reverse our thinking. If the Google Hybrid (and google earth) have a given location, it is more difficult to reverse our mistake. In King Edward, for some reason the Google label is now on the north peak. It is Mt King Edward.

  6. Guidebooks
     If guidebooks and literature tend to refer to the highest peak by the well known name, then our label should be on the high point. Eg: All the literature referring to climbs of Shulaps Peak is referring to the highest point, not to the obscure bump on the map. Labelling the bump as Shulaps I suspect was truly an error.

  7. Mountaineering References
     If the two summits are usually referred to using the same name (nort summit and south summit), that suggests that the label should be on the highest point. Eg:King Edward have never had two separate peaks in guidebooks or never had two names. Rick Colliers route description discusses "south summit and north summit". This implies it is one peak and it would be unnatural to have a separate name for the higher south summit.

  8. Well known Name
     If the name is a well known name of a high prominence peak, that gives more incentive to put that name on the highest point. Eg: King Edward. However not if the higher peak is too far away such as the Warner Peak case. Lyell is a case for consideration.

  9. When Applied
     If the name is deliberately applied recently to a lower point, then we should't move that name. Particularly if the name isn't some well established name. Eg: the official name "Mount Routh" was deliberately applied to the south peak in 1991, which overrides Mike Cleven's previous designation of a higher peak further north. That tends to favor putting the label on the south peak, even though there is a unnamed peak 1.2km away that is higher.

  10. Range Name
     Eg: There is an official Shulaps Range, thus we would expect the highest peak to be Shulaps Peak.

  11. location of cairns

3. Examples Summary Table
Below is a summary of certain peaks showing only the distance and prominence. As you can see, the Distance and Prominence alone don't give you the answer. With Frosty Mountain, we designate the highest point to be Frosty Mountain, even though it has a lot of prominence, because overwhelmingly it is referred as such.


 Situation Distance Prominence Designated -------------------------------------------------------------- Shulaps Peak 1.3 41m Yes King Edward 0.8 10m Yes Mount Routh 1.2 79m No Frosty Mountain 0.8 119m Yes Mount Warner 2.0 68m No

Column Headings:

  1. "Situation" is the well known name, as opposed to a name we might assign to the other peak. Sometimes the well known name is left on the lowest peak (Routh) whereas in other cases we move the well known name to the highest point (Shulaps)

  2. Distance refers to the distance between the two points, and prominence refers to the prominence of the low point with respect to the highest point.

  3. Prominence refers to the prominence of the lowest of the two points.

  4. Designated: Yes means that we moved the label to the highest point.


 - In the case of Frosty Mountain, we designate the highest summit to be Frosty Mountain.

4. Frosty Mountain
Frosty Mountain is the highest summit in Manning Provincial Park. The peak has two summits: the lower east summit (2410m/7900') and less than 1 km away, a higher west summit (7950' on map). On the 1:50K map, the point labelled "Frosty Mountain" is 7900', but 1 km to the northwest is a higher peak labelled 7950'. For purposes of this encyclopedia, we designate the highest point to be the "true" Mount Frosty, and the east peak to be a sub summit.

 Definition: Frosty is highest summit in Manning Park
 Distance Apart: 0.8 km
 Location of Label: 1:50 is on east summit
 Separate Name: No
 Separate Peak in Bivouac: Yes
 Well Known: Yes

This decision could go either way. Certainly the majority of people who say they've climbed Mount Frosty would be referring to the lower summit. And it's sufficient work to reach the higher summit from the lower summit that it could have a separate name. But then you'd contradict the statement that Frosty is the highest peak in Manning Park.

5. Shulaps Peak
Shulaps Peak is discussed in various guidebooks as being the highest point of the Shulaps Range. However the old 1:50K map had the label on a minor bump 1 km NW. We have always designated the high point as being Shulaps Peak. Mostly because guidebooks.

If you went to climb Shulaps, you most certainly would climb the highest point. (Unlike Frosty which has a trail up the lower peak).

 Prominence: 41 m
 Distance: 1.3 km
 Name: well known
 Guidebooks: highest peak
 Range Name: Highest point of Shulaps Range

6. King Edward
Mount King Edward is a ridge like peak. The latest TRIM map shows the highest point to be 3453m at the south end and 3440m at the north end. Rick Collier refers to these as the "South Summit" and "North Summit". But old 1:50K maps and Toporama show the label somewhere nearer the north end. Bivouac "designates" that the summit of King Edward to be the south summit.

Factors:
 - Distance between peaks (less than 1 km)
 - distinctness of the two peaks (no closed contour)
 - when 1:50 label was placed (decades ago)
 - Google Label (as of 2022 it is on the north end!)
 - guidebooks (make no distinction)
 - name for other peak (north summit)
 - precision of the label: the 1abel on the old 1:50K was clearly at the north end. The label on Toporama

It was named a long time ago. According to Boles, et al., this peak was named by Mary Schaffer in honour of Edward VII (1841-1910). So the intention was to name the whole peak as King Edward, and thus the label belongs on the highest point.

Rick Collier's description seems to indicate the south summit, where he found the cairn. He mentions the north summit

As of 2022, we do not have a peak record for the north summit, and neither does anybody else. And there is no name of the south summit.

7. Mount Routh
Mount Routh is in an obscure area which has two summits north and south, 1.2 km apart, 2009m and 2023m. Prominence is 79m Mount Routh is an official name applied fairly recently in 1991. It is not labelled on older 1:50K map. BC Basemap shows puts the label on the south summit. Glenn Woodsworth has researched this.

  Two Peaks in Bivouac: No (till 2022)
 In guidebooks: No
 Google Label: North Peak
 BC Basemap Label: South Peak
 1:50K Label: None
 Frequent Visits: No
 Distance: 1200m
 Prominence: 79m
 Origin: 1991, military
 Obscure: Yes

If we put the well known name on a lower summit, then we have to put in the second summit in order for prominence info to be correct.

Origin: Named to remember Canadian Army Corporal Patrick Albert Darnley Routh, K85370, from Vancouver. Serving in Italy with Princess Patricia's Canadian Light Infantry, RCIC, when he was killed in action 23 May 1944, age 24. Buried at Cassino War Cemetery, Italy, grave IX. B. 5. Parents: Albert and Cherrie Meredith Routh, Vancouver. [Note: Cpl Routh's older brother, John, was killed in action 9 months later; see Routh Islet]

Originally up till 2022, we had the title of Mount Routh on the highest point, the north peak. But in 2022, Glenn Woodsworth recommended that we put the south peak into the database and give it the official title "Mount Routh".

Arguments in favor are:
 - the BC Basemap and BCGNIS both label the south
 - the two peaks are more than 1 km apart
 - the lower peak has high prominence 79m

Arguments against:
 - Google already has the north peak as Routh
 - the peak is obscure area
 - we don't have a name for High Point. (but that doesn't matter that much because it is rarely discussed. This isn't like Frosty Mountain.

8. Mount Warner
The official label for Mount Warner is on the southern end of something called Warner Ridge. The highest point of Warner Ridge is about 2 km north. We call it "Sluice Peak".

 North Sluice: 2894m
 South Mount Warner: 2829m

 Distance: 2.0 km
 Prominence: 68m
 Refrences: none
 Well Known: yes

In this case, the deciding factor is distance. Sluice is too far from the official label Warner Peak for Warner to be designated. There is no guidebook references to Sluice as being the north peak of Warner.

9. Correction Policy
When do we reverse the designated name? It is more of a concern to reverse the location of a label if Google has already adopted our original idea. Eg: Mount Routh, google already has the label on the higher north summit, which argues against us moving the name to the south summit.

However, in this case we reversed it anyway, because we deem to have made a mistake. The high point designated is more than 1 km from the official. Another factor is that we can clearly argue that the official was "deliberately" placed in 1991 on the south summit.

In general we don't reverse borderline cases unless the argument is pretty strong for doing so.