Bivouac.com   Home     Help   Index   SignUp   Login
Names of Peaks In the Selkirks - Policy Specification #1646
    Date first written: 2008.07.27   Review Date:2016.07.21

There are several places in the Selkirks, where the names on the government maps are not the same as in David Jones guidebooks. David Jones is the leading guidebook author in this area, and has spent a lot of time researching mountain history, trying to straighten up the names. Bivouac is now co-ordinating the names with him for his future guidebooks. In the past, some of his names violated the bivouac name principles, so we didn't adopt the names he created. In some cases he lost historical names, and in some cases he "swaps" names.

Here is the Bivouac database policy:

(1) To only document peaks that have distinct contour lines on the government maps.
 (2) To use the official government name, if clear and available.
 (3) To resolve confusion by using a new and distinct name if necessary.
 (4) To immediately fix any instance which does not conform with the policy.

If a government name is "wrong" according to what climbers may have intended during first ascents, we wait until the government name is corrected. Otherwise, we regard the original climber's name as an interesting historical fact, but not the official name.

The problem in the Selkirks is that the official government names disagree with various historical artifacts on various low prominence peaks. David Jones has attempted to correct these mistakes, and thus his guidebook applies the official names to different peaks. This is confusing, because then one must say "Jones's Gargoyles" or "Government Gargoyles" to know what you are talking about.

How did the government database get so bad? It happened because they had a policy of accepting names that were likely to cause future trouble. They should not have accepted names for features that did not show clearly on their own maps. Because they did, they often put the labels in the wrong place. Nobody knew what the submitter was talking about. The other cause of confusion is the acceptance of names which were semantically confusing. In particular, they should not have accepted names such as "The Gothics" as applying to a single peak. In summary:

1. They accepted names for peaks that did not show on their maps
  2. They accepted plural names for peaks. (The Gothics)
  3. If the location of a submitted name is unclear, put the label onto the map anyway. Just find a likely location.

Unfortunately David Jones has not solved all the problems. To discuss his effort, first we should lay out what appears to be his policy, and then we can comment on the results:

(1) To document ALL peaks of interest, not just peaks that show on the maps.
 (2) If government names are confused, make corrections as necessary, regardless of whether the government accepts the change. This includes swapping names.
 (3) To assign "explanation" names such as "East Peak of the Gothics" or "False Findhorn" rather than creating an unambigous name for the peak.

The results of this policy are confusion, because in most cases, people will still be using government maps. Furthermore, to do what we assume he is trying to do, he should at least have a format that clearly lays out the location of each of his peaks, so readers can match it to a map. Ideally, he would show both the WGS 84 Grid refence, and the Lat-Long. If he also wants to give one of the old NAD27 grid references that is also fine, but the other two are increasingly essential. NAD 27 does not exist in BC Basemap, and is rapidly being replaced on Federal 1:50000 maps as well.

History and Analysis:
It is our view that ANY names database requires a SPECIFICATION as to what is supposed to be in the database. A specification is the key to maintainance of the database. There must be a mechanism whereby users of the database can report errors from the specification. The specification should be in writing somewhere, and must be simple enough that it is feasible to make timely corrections. Otherwise, people don't know what is an error, or what is likely to be fixed.

The need for a specification became evident early in the Bivouac database. The first problem we had was that numerous editors were inserting features into the mountain database which did not show up on maps. Then trouble reports would arrive telling us these features were in the wrong place. Showing on the map is essential to timely correction. Without a specification, you soon have people reporting problems that are hard to correct, or are left in limbo.

The first Bivouac policy and specification (which was well documented) was to have a "prominence rule", whereby peaks would only be in the database if they had more than 300m of vertical separation. This was similar to the standard US Government policy which required 500' of separation. However, this specification was a bit too strict, so the minimum became 100m, and then even 50m in certain locations of interest. We also discovered that it was practical to have some minimum horizontal separation, in order to find duplicate entries. Thus we chose the standard that peaks must have at least 200m of horizontal separation.

We also adopted certain semantic rules such as not adopting names that were plurals, or names that referred to peaks as "ridges".

These rules have paid off many times. The horizontal separation rule allows us to find and fix cases where a given peak is put into the database twice, but with slightly different coordinates.

So what should Bivouac do about the Selkirks? We could adopt a policy that David Jones IS the authority, not the government. The problem is how to make corrections. We receive dozens of emails a week pointing out errors, and each of them is investigated in a timely fashion. Its simple - look it up on the map, and fix the database. Our goal is to have a clearly stated specification of what we are doing, and then deal with any trouble reports by referring to the specification. We guarantee to look into any situation where the database does not match the specification.

So here is a restatement of the policy:

1. Any feature recorded as a "mountain" in the Bivouac database must show up on the government maps.

2. For swapped names, we use the government database, until officially fixed. The definitive example of this policy is the case of Shadowfax and Gandalf.

3. Confused Names will be renamed.
 In cases where the government says one thing, but the majority of guidebooks say something else, or in the case where names are semantically confusing (plurals), we may assign some whole new name to the peak, so we always have a clear and unchanging description of what we mean. Eg: We refer to the peak at 51:43:49-117:53:05 as "Crimean Peak", although the goverment label for "The Gothics" is nearby, and may refer to this peak. And Jones refers to this peak as "East Peak of the Gothics".

4. Any Alternate names in common use will be listed in the "alternate names" field, so they can be found by searching. Eg: The Gargoyle (Govt).

Results of these policies in the Selkirks:

  1. Eyrie Peak On government map, this peak is called "The Gargoyle" but Jones says that the true location of the Gargoyle is in another place that doesn't even show up as a peak on the 20m maps. Our solution is to assign a new name "Eyrie Peak" to the distinct peak shown on the maps at 51:43:34-117:52:58 WGS84. We then include both "The Gargoyle", and "Post Peak" as alternate names, so if someone is searching for this name, they find the peak.

  2. Crimean Peak This peak is called "The Gothics" plural by the government, and is called "East Peak of the Gothics" by Jones. Neither of these names is a good name, the government name is a plural, and Jones name is a sentence.

  3. Golem Peak (For Gargoyle)
      David Jones says the Gargoyle is "200m SE of his East Peak of the Gothics", which is Crimean Peak. Jones Gargoyle would be the ridge at about 51:43:45-117:52:52 (WGS84). However that ridge does not show up as a peak on any map, and therefore is not entered as a peak into Bivouac. So Jones would say that Bivouac does not include The Gargoyle as a peak.

  4. Blackfriars Peak.
     We refer to the highest peak in the Blackfriars peaks as "Blackfriars Peak" (singular). We regard the name "Blackfriars Peaks" to be the name of more than one peak, and thus such a name cannot be applied to a single point.

  5. FindHorn Peak In this case, we stick with the name as it appears on government maps and leave Mount McBean.