I'm sure I've written this out somewhere else, but I can't find it. So here it is.
One Bivouac policy that is often misunderstood is the policy of making sure that the names of peaks are not confused with the names of ridges. To understand the reason for this standard, you have to look at history. In the beginning, Bivouac used to insert mountain records for things like "Endless Chain Ridge", and use the lat-long of the highest point as the location. And this policy was carried on by various Bivouac editors when creating names for unnamed features.
But the first sign of problems was a bunch of trouble tickets relating to a feature called "Rune Ridges". It took quite a while to figure out what was going on, because of the semantic confusion in the names. What happened was that a bivouac editor, Drew Brayshaw, had assigned the name "Rune Ridges" to a subpeak of Mount Lamont in the Chahalis area. It turned out that he wanted to call the whole ridge system containing Mount Lamont "Rune Ridges", and the most convenient way to get that name onto the map was to name one of the subpeaks "Rune Ridges".
After spending quite a bit of time cleaning up the confusion in various photos, trip reports and trails referring to Rune Ridges, I decided that we needed to have much stricter semantic rules for ridge and peak names. The need was not confined to Rune Ridges, there were hundreds of other official name examples like Endless Chain Ridge. This "ridge" is 11 km long. Yet it contains at least 7 peaks. We wanted separate names for every peak.
So we came up with the rule that the "peak" names would contain a name like peak, mountain, or mount, and we would use the ridge names for AREA features. So the Endless Chain Ridge is an AREA in Bivouac, and the highest PEAK is Shackle Peak. (Previously the highest peak was called "Endless Chain Ridge" in Bivouac).
So I started investigating the things called "ridge" in Bivouac, and in almost every case, when you looked on the maps, you'd see the name sprawled across a whole area. This supports the argument that it is the name of a ridge and NOT the name of a peak. And trying to put it into a database as the name of a peak was just some shortcut devised by some guidebooks, but not really the intention of the GSC.
There was some opposition to this policy by some Bivouac members who said that such a policy was not workable, and that "ridge" was a descriptive word for the shape of the mountain, just like "needle" or "spire".
Panorama Ridge. As a test case, the battle lines were drawn around Panorama Ridge. If the principle is universally workable, then it should work there as well as anywhere else. My side of the argument is that Panorama Peak and Panorama Ridge are two different concepts - one is the ridge, and the other is the highest point on the ridge. But the other side of the argument is that both concepts are called Panorama Ridge, and that any attempt to introduce a name for the point was renaming the mountain. The key issue is: was the ridge named Panorama Ridge, or was the peak named panorama ridge?
The key evidence of the intention is the 1:50,000 topo maps for that area. On those maps, you can see that there are two typefaces: ridges are labelled with the name sprawling across the area of the ridge, and peaks are labelled with a much more compact, and upright font.
So we put in a separate point record called Panorama Peak, which is contained in Panorama Ridge. The argument would be simpler if there were multiple peaks on the ridge, such as Endless Chain. But its much simpler to have just one standard.
So this is the key case that you'll hear arguments about. The way I've most often heard the argument is that "R Tivy the dictator, is going around renaming officially named peaks".
I don't think that's a fair statement of what is going on. I have not renamed Panorama Ridge. The name still exists, as always. The name Panorama Peak is just the name of the highest point, which was previously unnamed.
Note:
As of 2011, I discovered that the US government Geographic Names Information System definitions are very clear on the distinction between a "summit (mountain, peak)" versus a "ridge", and say explicitly that a "Summit" cannot be called a ridge.
Ridge
Elevation with a narrow, elongated crest which can be part of a hill or mountain (crest, cuesta, escarpment, hogback, lae, rim, spur).
Summit
Prominent elevation rising above the surrounding level of the Earth's surface; does not include pillars, ridges, or ranges (ahu, berg, bald, butte, cerro, colina, cone, cumbre, dome, head, hill, horn, knob, knoll, mauna, mesa, mesita, mound, mount, mountain, peak, puu, rock, sugarloaf, table, volcano).
Range
Chain of hills or mountains; a somewhat linear, complex mountainous or hilly area (cordillera, sierra).