Revised 2011.04.01. This page explains the financial history and costs of running the Bivouac website, so you know where your money is going. I've always found that an "open books" policy is good, because there is a HUGE amount of volunteer effort that goes into Bivouac, and people feel a lot better if they know the basic facts. I've been doing it for 15 years now, so here's the story.
To run Bivouac, I initially considered setting up a non-profit society. But non-profit is the wrong model if somebody personally has to come up with a lot of money. The Non-profit model is good if the startup capital is coming from a government grant. So I set up a simple company I called "Bluesoft". Its main purpose is to create and run the Bivouac website - it doesn't do much else. I then poured a big chunk of my own money into the company. This enabled the company to buy all the equipment, and sign a lease on the office space.
I must admit I looked into various government grants/loans, looking for free money. But what I found out was that to get government money, you needed all sorts of bogus "business plans". (We used to do them for companies when I was getting my MBA.) The pattern that is all too common: you make up a glorious pro-forma statement, showing ever increasing revenues, and promising to pay back the government loan at a high rate of interest. If you actually were successful, it would be a really expensive loan, because the interest rate was high.
However, the way the game is played is that once you get the big start up capital, you pay yourself a good salary, and everything looks great for a couple of years. But once you've spent the initial capital, unless you get more government money, you go out of business. But its still worth it for the entrepreneur because he got a salary even though the company went under. That's OK, you just get involved in another "entrepreneur venture", and do it all again.
Government grants are a bad deal if all you have is a modest plan, and you really intend to stay in business for many years. Which is what I wanted to do.
So I used my own life's savings. And its been worth it, because its the most important and successful thing I've been involved in for my whole working career. It is difficult to imagine I'll ever get the initial money I put into this thing back. My goal for the last few years has been to hold the line, and not lose any more money. This ensures that if something happened to me, at least someone else could take over the website knowing it pays for itself. As you probably know, anything that has no hope of ever paying for itself will eventually be shut down once the "grant" runs out.
So here are the numbers you can write down on the back of an envelope as you do your analysis. For the years 1995-2010, Bluesoft owned its own servers and rented an office. In those years, Telus used to charge me $1100/month for a T1 line (internet connection). The office was 2500/month, and my share (for Bivouac) was $1000/month, which provided room for several key volunteers like Fred Touche, Mike Cleven and others to work on-site for years. During those years, Bluesoft spent a lot of money to get Bivouac going, gather all the data, and reach critical mass. Below are the typical expenses during those years:
Those 37,000/year expenses were not a dead loss, because from year 2001 on, Bivouac was a pay website, and there was revenue from subscribers and even a few advertisers. But we still lost money every year, but it kept getting bigger and better. That was the expansion stage.Per Year
Office Rent 12000
Internet connection 13200
Backup power, network eqpt 500
2 Servers (Depr) 6000
4 Workstations (Depr) 2000
Reimbursements 4000
Maps and supplies 1000
---------
37,000
I was always looking for ways to cut costs. I always knew I was paying too much for the T1 Internet connection. I had started with an ISDN line, which was only $700/month, but then a customer had forced me to upgrade to the T1, at $1100. Every time I phoned Telus, they told me nothing else was available, if I was running the servers). But eventually, after numerous studies, cheaper methods appeared and we got out of the Telus contract. So then the internet line costs went down to $300/month by using a different internet company.
But the big change was last year when we closed the office. At that time I switched to a different business model: let someone else manage our server at a remote data center. (It needs to be on its own server due to all the specialized code, and due to the special RAID configuration on the hardware, extra disk drives, and backup server.) It's still pretty expensive, when you add in the costs of having data backup to a standby servers, etc. (Unlike the nuclear power plants in Japan, I actually have all sorts of backup systems and standby equipment, and disaster analysis.) I always thought it would be a horrible disaster if somehow we lost all the work people have done over the years.
And disasters do happen. It is quite common for companies to think they have backup, only to find out it doesn't really work when the crunch comes. I have made the same discovery myself. Anyway, now that the site is at a data center, it is much cheaper than it was for the years we had an office.
So below is the current summary of the expenses budget:
Expenses
Home Office 1200
Server and backup at Data Center 3600
Home ADSL Connection, phone 600 //some offsite backup
Machine repair and upgrade 4000 //always testing new stuff
Projects and supplies 5000
Reimbursements 2000
Other 1500
-------
So why did it all cost so much for so many years? Why couldn't I have just run the whole thing out of my basement the whole time? Why was the office essential? The payoff from the office was that we had a common workplace for all the people working on the project. There were other technology companies sharing the office, and a lot of the key technology for Bivouac was learned from others in the office. Its a lot harder to do this from home.
Back in 1995, all the services that exist nowdays did not exist. We ran our own mail servers, our own DNS server, and had two backup servers for the main server. And all these machines needed CRT monitors, many of which cost $2100 each. I just can't believe it that we bought all that stuff. Even the office phone system (which we scrapped last year) cost 10,000. I guess we should have had a government grant.