Bivouac.com   Home     Help   Index   SignUp   Login
Properties of a Good Name #723
    Date first written: 2006.03.07   Review Date:2022.01.03

See Master List of Peak Name Documents (Deciding between two possible names). Use this document to help pick the best name from two names under consideration. It gives the properties of a good name. All other things being equal, what we want is a short, pronounceable, unique, single word name.

First off, we must reject any name that could not eventually become official. This includes names of living people, or trivial names that relate to inside jokes. And we also avoid names that are semantically confusing, such as "Ridge", or any plural name such as "Xyz Peaks" or "Three Sisters".

But assuming it is not one of these, we do not use a strict hierarchy of factors. Rather, the decision is based on weighing various factors in favor of each name. So for example, if one of the names was used by the first ascent party, but another name was used casually by locals before that, we wouldn't say one source has absolute priority over the other. We would instead look at all aspects of the two names, and choose the best.

Case 1: Bivouac name is superior according to our rules, and other website name is not well established.

  1. Short
     A short, easy to spell name is best for maps, so the name can easily be fitted into larger scale maps. Ideally less than 8 characters, and the shorter the better. A short name is a better identifier. So we try to avoid names like "Fifty Years of Alaska Statehood".

  2. Phonetic
     Since this is an english encyclopedia, "phonetic" means that you can sound out the name in english. A short phonetic name serves better than one that large numbers of people would have difficulty pronouncing. Many of the earlier native names are very good names. For example "Atna Peak" is a pronounceable native name. Long names the average person cannot pronounce aren't very useful for maps.

  3. Minimum Syllables
     A name with one or two syllables is preferable to a 5 syllable name, even if it is two words instead of one. Thus "Rain Door" is better than Oinimitus.

  4. Easy to Spell
     All other things being equal, an easy to spell name trumps a hard to spell name.

  5. Single word
     All other things being equal, a one word name is better than a two word name.

  6. Standard English Characters
     Bivouac is an english dictionary, so all names consist of the 26 standard characters. This ensures that the maps stay usable.

  7. Avoid Punctuation
     Best names are entirely alphabetic and do not have quotes, dashes, etc. Eg: D'Arcy is an unfortunate official name.

  8. Distinct Root word
     Avoid having the same root word appear in two nearby peaks. Eg: It is not good to have "Hall Peak" and "Hallway Peak" or "Back Hall Peak". Better to have distinct names like Hall, Stair, Triangle. The problem with having a root word like "Hall" appearing in multiple places is one sometimes thinks it is a shortening.

  9. Unique in geographic area
     We try to get a unique name for each peak within its province or state. Eg: "Goat Peak" is not a good name regardless of other factors. Or at least unique within 200 km.

  10. Mountain Related
     A name that relates to the physical characteristics of the mountain is good. For example, Cloudraker, Icemaker, and Longspur are good names.

  11. Meaningful Event
     In creating a provisional name, it is good if it refers to something that most people would understand and find meaningful. Ideally the description of the event would be something you could look up if you wanted to understand the name. For example, "Mount Good Hope" is a good name because it refers to a huge event in World War I, and would be something anyone could look up. Similarly, Birkenhead, and Seton are reasonable names.

  12. Notable National Name
     Notable national names, which would have some meaning at the national level are good. For example, Canadian names like Wilfrid Laurier or Louis Riel, or Klatsassin. (Note that all three of these there is readily accessible information in Google or Wikipedia). However, this doesn't mean that a Canadian name "trumps" everything. There are many international events or people that might be equally meaningful to Canadians. For example, the name of some obscure local politician doesn't necessarily trump a name like Good Hope or Monmouth.

  13. Notable Local
     The names of Notable local people from the area of the peak are good names. "Notable" means significant to more than just his relatives. In adopting names of locals, we avoid suggested names that are merely applied to make ones relatives famous.

  14. Theme Related
     If the name relates to a theme already established by other officially named peaks in the area, then it gets extra points. (Eg: Battle of Coronel theme for peaks around Goddard Glacier.

  15. Name Proposed by first ascent party
     Names proposed by the first ascent party are good. But it doesn't necessarily trump any other possible name if the first ascent party try to name things after themselves, or inside jokes, etc.

  16. Published
     All other things being equal, a name published in journals, guidebooks, newsletters or reports is superior to one just created.

  17. Non ASCII names
     The design and intent of the Bivouac encyclopedia is to be english and confined to the 26 roman characters a-z. Names recently created in other character sets are not to be used in the main title that appears on the english maps. Instead such names are handled by the alternate name field. If suitable, the main name can be a short anglicized version of that name. Some of the recent government "names" do not work with the scope of this encyclopedia.

  18. Avoid "Correction Prefixes"
     Sometimes guidebooks try to rectify historical errors by attaching prefixes like "true" and "false" to the original name. Eg: In Washington, there is an officially labelled "Fire Mountain", which is sometimes labelled as "False Fire Mountain" and a peak 1 km to the NW is labelled "True Fire Mountain". It is better to avoid this. It is better to assign the unlabelled peak an entirely distict name. (Eg: Candle Peak".)