Table of Contents
1. Prominence walks never cross rivers
2. EVERY saddle is a prominence saddle for something
3. Each saddle is only used once
4. Prominence Threshold Guarantees the PP Agree
5. Unique Prominence Parent Rule (No ridge forks)
6. Prominence is independent of database
7. Surrogate Saddles
1. Prominence walks never cross rivers
The "prominence walk" is the route along the highest ridges that gets you to higher ground. These prominence walks NEVER cross rivers or streams. Proof: Suppose someone argues that the key saddle of a peak is at a river crossing. You can easily point out that you could stay higher just by crossing the stream further upstream. The highest route to get to the other side of any stream is to go around its source.
The rule that prominence walks never cross streams is very useful when searching for key saddles. If you look at a simple map showing streams and peak heights, you can fairly quickly find which direction you have to go to get higher ground. I often use the Bivouac javamap for this purpose.
Don't confuse streams with lakes. There are a few rare passes that have lakes or small ponds in them that flow both ways. For example, Committee's punch bowl in Athabasca pass flows both into Atlantic and Pacific oceans. However, obviously there is no pass where water flows uphill thru the pass and down the other side.
2. EVERY saddle is a prominence saddle for something
(2003.10.27) Every saddle is the key saddle for exactly one peak. The peak may not be in the database, but it must exist. I got this wrong the first time, and was corrected by prominence expert Edward Earl.
Proof: Here's how you can find the peak that goes with any saddle. Any saddle represents the point where two contour loops touch. (Contour loop is a closed contour line). Locate the highest peak inside each loop. The lower of these peaks is the peak whose prominence saddle is the one you choose, and the higher is its prominence island "parent".
Another way of stating this rule is that the number of saddles is always equal to the number of peaks less one peak. Think of an island. At first you have just one big peak and no saddles. Then if you add a second peak, you have 1 key saddle that joins the lower peak to the higher. If you add a third peak, now you have 2 saddles and 3 peaks. Every peak has a saddle that joins it to the higher peak. Only the highest peak on the whole island doesn't have a saddle joining it to some higher peak.
There is one theoretical type of saddle that isn't the key saddle of any peak, and that is a "basin saddle". A basin saddle is the low point on a ridge surrounding a basin. If you draw the contour for a ridge that almost forms a circle around a dry basin, you will have such a saddle. In Canada, basins are rare because they are usually filled with water.
3. Each saddle is only used once
A saddle can only be used by one peak. If you see two key saddles in the same place, one of them is wrong. One of those peaks must have its key saddle somewhere else. For example, Yellowhead pass links Mount Robson to the higher ground in the USA, and no other peak uses that link. Any other peak on the Robson side should ultimately be linked to Robson. Any other peak on the south side should ultimately be linked to the highest point on that prominence island.
In a two way saddle, no two subpeaks can be linked to a parent peak via the same saddle, because the lower of the two sibling peaks could always be linked to the higher sibling by going almost down to the col then turning back up to the other peak, and thus staying higher.
People have disputed this rule by hypothesizing possible "three way saddles" such as shown below:
<img src=Modx/img/pgx/186_SharedCol.jpg>
However, the above situation is unlikely to occur in nature, because one of the divides always erodes away slightly faster than the other, and then you have two separate passes. In the entire database, we do not have one case of a triple saddle. The closest thing are the two saddles near Valemount.
Since no two saddles can be in the same place, you can now quickly find errors by displaying one of the peak and saddle maps, such as the GMapForm link or the TRIM link on every mountain page.
4. Prominence Threshold Guarantees the PP Agree
When reconciling two databases, there must be agreement that they are complete to a certain "prominence threshold" Eg: (Eg: Guarantee the list contains all P1000 peaks). Given a certain completeness guarantee, two databases must agree as to what is the Prominence Parent (Greater Parent) for any given high prominence peak. They may not agree on line parents, because one database could contain low prominence bumps the other does not.
Consider the following 5 peaks, all on Peakbagger may have the following prominence lineage:
Peak Height Prom Saddle -----------------------------------
Peak A 2000 1500 500
Peak B 2100 200 1900
Peak C 2200 400 1800
Peak D 2800 1100 1700
Peak E 3000 1600 1400
Bivouac might just have Peak A and have Peak D as Line Parent and E as prominence parent. (And doesn't even have Peak B and C as peaks) Peakbagger might have the whole chain of 5 peaks, such that the LP of peak A is B and the prom parent is E.
But in order for both peak lists to qualify as "complete P1000" lists, they both must contain Peaks A, D and E. You can't skip peak D.
5. Unique Prominence Parent Rule (No ridge forks)
(Ridges never fork) Prominence walk to prominence parent must follow the highest ridge line. "Highest ridge line" means at any given point as you climb up toward the parents, you take the highest route. Thus the prominence parents should always agree.
There is only one correct ridge walk from a given peak to it's Line and prominence parent. There is no such thing as a fork where you could go to either of two possible parents. One will be the true parent, and the other not. A wrong parent may serve to "prove" the key saddle is correct, but it is not the correct ridge line.
In an earlier rule, we stated that a well formed database must both have designate the same "Greater Peak". There is only one correct ridge walk. When doing Baffin Island, I would often see two possible peaks that might be the prominence parent. Both higher prominence than the subject peak. which one is the true parent? You can't just say either one, because although either one is reachable without going below the key saddle elevation, the highest ridge line goes only to one. "Highest ridge line" means at any given point, you take the highest route.
Although different databases may not agree on Line Parent, there is only one correct ridge walk to the prominence parent. There is no such thing as having a choice between two different ridges. Ridges do not fork when going upwards - one is always slightly higher.
I tried to imagine a situation where the prom walk is going up a ridge and you come to a fork between two ridges such that you could go up either one of them and eventually reach either one of two higher peaks. But when you try to draw a contour and stream diagram of such a situation, I found out that you are always on one side or the other of the drainage coming down from the upper saddle between the two ridges.
Imagine an island with the lowest contour 100 feet. For convenience, label the contours in even hundreds, eg: The "1' contour, the "2' contour, etc. Make all the contours closed contours
- draw a big closed 100 foot contour, that is the whole island
- At the south end, draw closed 200, 300, 400 foot contours. This is peak "A"
- Key saddle: Draw a big closed 200' contour enclosing the north end of the island. The space between the two 200' contours is the key saddle.
So the saddle is between 1 and 2 hundred feet.
- Now make the ridge continue north by making the closed contour 2 pinch in further north.
- define peaks B and C with two closed 300' contours. In the center between the two 300' contours is the "upper saddle" between peaks "B" and "C". In the space above, try and draw the fork such that there are two ridges coming down (two closed 300' contours) that come together just north of where the 200 foot contour pinches in.
- complete the two separate upper ridges with closed contours 3 and 4 each. And a final contour 5 around peak "B"
- put another closed 300' contour on the lower part of the ridge before you get to the bulge. That is peak "D" which is just a bump on the way to the parent
Now we have things set up so we can hypothesize that either B or C could be the parent. When you get to the upper saddle, it looks like you could go either way. However when you put in a stream coming down from the 300+ saddle, that stream starts out coming south, but must go either east or west before getting to Peak D. Streams cannot normally fork. It would eventually erode to going either one way or the other. Such that when you ridge walk north you end up being on either one side or the other of that stream, and that forces you up either one or the other possible parent peak. Eg; If the stream drains off on the east side of the ridge, then you are forced to the west peak. You might imagine you could somehow skirt around the top of the stream and thus continue to the east peak but that involves going down slightly to get to that upper saddle, whereas the true prom walk stays higher by going west.
6. Prominence is independent of database
For any given peak, the location of its key saddle and its prominence are fixed and absolute, regardless of what peaks are in the database. The prominence does not depend on what other peaks may or may not be in the database. A peaks prominence only depends on where the lowest point is between the given peak and some higher ground beyond. The higher ground does not have to be designated as a peak. The concept of "line parent" is just a convenient way to point out some higher ground.
Furthermore, you can always work out the key saddle and prominence of any given peak regardless of what else might be in the database. For example, you can figure out the prominence of Mount Robson without any other peaks in the database. You just have to trace the entire ridge line and look for the the lowest pass before you get to higher ground (way down in the states). However, to cut down on the number of saddles you have to consider, it is often easier to square away as many intermediate ones as possible beforehand, so you are only left having to compare the really deep saddles.
7. Surrogate Saddles
Surrogate saddles are nearby substitutes for the real "key saddle" of a peak. It is better to use a surrogate saddle than it is to leave the peak with zero prominence. This allows the system to work correctly. For example, if somebody wants to see all the peaks in the coast range with a prominence of greater than 1000m, they could search for everything greater than 800m and be pretty sure that at least they have all the candidates.
Put the word "surrogate" into the key saddle field:
Key Saddle: Surrogate Col 30-14
Saddle Height: 3000
Parent:
Just leave the "Parent" blank.